***If you’re looking for the most recent reviews for 2021 gear, we will be updating this page in the summer after we’ve had a chance to review them!
If you’re in a hurry and just want to find the Best Golf Balls for Average Golfers (Mid Handicappers) in 2020, then we recommend the Titleist Tour Soft (2020 Version).
Aside from your club of choice, your golf ball might just be the next most important golf equipment purchase you will make. Without a ball, you can neither hit your next great shot nor can you shank the next one into the woods. If you are in the vast majority of golfers, then you are what would be considered “average” in your skills. You are probably inconsistent, struggle with your short game, but hit a few shots each round that make you think you could be great. At this skill level, it is important to find the best golf balls for average golfers to help shave a stroke or two from your score. The rest of this article will attempt to help you do just that.
In this article, we’re going to be reviewing the following golf balls:
- Titleist Tour Soft (2020 Version)
- Srixon Q-Star Tour 2
- TaylorMade Tour Response
- Callaway ERC Soft
- Bridgestone e12 Soft
What is an average golfer?
An average golfer is someone who could lose three balls on a par five one day and then come back the next day and putt for eagle. They can hit a 300 yard bomb down the middle of the fairway one hole and then hook one into the woods the next. The average male golfer has a 13.0 handicap. That means, if you are “average” you probably shoot anywhere between 80 and 92 on a par 72 course. Anyone who averages better than that is good and anyone who averages worse than that probably should not even calculate their handicap yet.
An average golfer can be someone who spends 10 hours per week on a golf course and has reached their top potential. But it can also be someone who spends 10 hours per month and just has a knack for swinging the sticks. The truth is, to be better than average you should work on your short game, and to get even better than that, spend an hour every day putting. The bottom line is that an average golfer spans a wide range of skill levels. That also means that the phrase “best golf balls for average golfers” can mean something different to different “average” golfers.
What are some important golf ball characteristics?
When purchasing a box of balls, there are 5 major things to consider:
What type of distance does the ball provide? Balls are tested with a machine guided club so that the same inputs go into each swing. When different balls are placed on the tee, you can easily see the different distances provided by different balls.
The materials used in each golf ball can be anywhere from 1-piece to 5-piece construction. The more “pieces” within the ball the better the mixture of spin, feel, and distance come together. With improved quality, however, almost always comes increased price.
The same machine guided club that tests for distance can also test for spin. You can purchase either low, mid, or high spin balls and your decision should be based on your specific swing. If you can pound the ball but have little to no idea where it will end up, a lower spin ball is probably for you. The less spin produced means you will have greater control. If control is not your problem but you want to increase draw or carry, then get a mid to high spin ball.
The feel of the golf ball is a hard thing to describe but an easy thing to experience on the course. It is how the ball bounces off of the club, how it sounds on contact, how it lands and sits on the green, and how it reacts to your attempts at a draw or a fade. The feel of a ball is something that you really have to experience, and if you are on the higher end of the handicap scale then you may not even understand this characteristic yet.
You do not need me to explain what it means for a golf ball to be durable. It lasts a long time, it reacts and travels as far on the 50th strike as it did on the 10th. Durability is not important if you lose a lot of balls or if you have a superstition that leads you to throw a ball out after a certain type of strike. But if you want to save some money while using high quality golf balls, durability is something that you should look into before purchasing.
What are some things for the average golfer to consider when purchasing golf balls?
Prior to spending a lot of money on a really good box of balls, consider the following questions. Remember, it is important to play with high quality equipment, but if you are not a solid player already a ball can only help you so much. These are some of the other considerations.
How many balls do I lose per round?
If you lose a lot of balls every time you play, stick to something cheap while you learn. You do not want to spend all of your time in the woods looking for the expensive golf ball you just sliced out of bounds. It is better to take the pressure off of yourself and use a ball you do not mind leaving behind.
What type of course do I play on regularly?
Are you playing more wide open city courses or tighter country club tracks? The more difficult the course, the cheaper the ball you will want to use. If you can “grip it and rip it” at every tee box, use an expensive ball and see how far you can drive it.
How consistent is my golf game?
If your game is not consistent then a ball is not going to make it any more so. Wait until you can do the same thing over and over again on the course and then splurge for some golf balls that will help to lower your scores.
Do I compete or play for fun?
If you always play just for fun, then there may be some “illegal” balls that will give you the same advantage of a 50 dollar box of balls at a 10 dollar price point.
Best Golf Balls For Average Golfers (Mid Handicappers) Reviewed
When you think of golf balls, you think of Titleist. They have always been on the cutting edge of high end golf balls.
The 2020 version of the Titleist Tour Soft is as soft on the green as ever, and this year’s version has some added distance that many will appreciate. While it does not offer the green side spin that the Pro V1 has, the playability of this golf ball at its price point is one of the best.
- An expanded core adds both distance and spin around the green.
- One of the softest landing balls on the market.
- Offers the softest feel at its price point.
- An updated dimple design improves the ball flight.
- A little more expensive than others on the list.
- Not as explosive as the other balls in its price range.
The Srixon Q-star Tour 2 focuses on feel at the expense of distance. It is an extremely soft ball around the greens and holds short game spin as well as any other club on the list.
The compression rating for this ball is very low compared to the other balls on this list and it takes away some needed distance.
- If you are willing to sacrifice distance for superior feel, this is the ball for you. Nothing is softer around the green.
- Described by Srixon as an ultra soft ball, it is a great description for how well this ball lands and sticks on the green.
- One of the least expensive balls on the list.
- If you are looking for a ball that provides extra distance, this is not your choice.
- The ball does not jump off of the driver or longer irons, but it also holds spin too well which makes mishits even worse.
The TaylorMade Tour Response ball was designed as a response after consulting the masses.
That means that TaylorMade asked for and received feedback from golfers across skill levels to figure out what they were looking for in a golf ball. The Tour Response is a result of feedback. The TaylorMade Tour Response is an affordable ball that uses the technology that most players want in a golf ball with a combination of distance and softness being the key.
- A low compression, high spring core allows for extra softness without losing ball speed and distance.
- One of the least expensive options at this level of golf ball.
- A cast urethane cover for increased spin around the green and greater durability.
- There is an extra casing layer around the core that allows for the low compression with high ball speed.
- It has good distance and good feel, but it is not an industry leader in either category.
- The lower price point makes it more accessible, but it also takes away from the bottom line performance of the ball.
The initials of the founder of Callaway Golf, Ely Reeves Callaway, can be found on this golf ball for the first time in a while.
Traditionally you find these initials on Callaway’s longest irons and drivers, but the company believes this is the longest and softest ball they have produced yet. With a tradition like Callaway’s, those are high expectations.
- The longest golf ball Callaway offers at this price point.
- Even with the added length, this is one of the softest balls in Callaway’s arsenal as well.
- A technologically advanced core that allows low compression while providing less spin, higher ball speed, and higher launch.
- The regular price of this ball is one of the most expensive on the list.
- The price point does not warrant the features, you might as well move up to their slightly more expensive top line balls.
A great price point for a great golf ball that is aimed at the “average” golfer.
It is a three piece ball that focuses on feel and ball speed together. There is an “Active Acceleration Mantle” layer that impacts thrust and initial velocity to increase your distance while the low compression core maintains your control. The dimple design reduces spin on long shots while the ball spins well and lands soft around the green.
- This ball allows for a very high launch and straight trajectory.
- It is extremely soft around the green.
- It simultaneously reduces spin off of the drive while maintaining good spin rates in your short game.
- A low compression core coupled with an acceleration mantle layer allow for a high launch, decent distance, and great softness and feel.
- The e12s are designed for slower swing players and average golfers.
- The compression rating of 50 is the lowest on this list and reduces the maximum distance that this ball will fly.
The Titleist Tour Soft is our pick because of the great control and feel that the ball produces.
While it may not be the longest ball on the market, it does hold its own in distance while providing the softest landing and best feel in the short game. Adding a couple of yards to a drive is nothing compared to keeping your drives straight, your short game sharp, and your approach shots soft and the Titleist does each of these things well.